writ. and dir. by Alex Garland
Horror and science fiction are both presently enjoying modest renaissance periods. For horror films, the likes of It Follows and The Witch provide clever twists on common horror motifs, whereas recent sci-fi marvels like Arrival and Blade Runner 2049 use their imaginative worlds to tell very human stories and explore fascinating philosophical concepts. Writer-director Alex Garland was at the forefront of the latter wave with his 2015 feature Ex Machina, a nebulous yet fascinating bit of speculative fiction which placed as much weight on the personalities of its leads as on the technology of its core. That film ultimately devolved into a deranged slasher film, high-energy but bland and comically overheated, but its questions lingered in the mind.
With his new film, an adaptation of Jeff VanderMeer's Annihilation, Garland has mixed the thoughtful science fiction of his prior film with foreboding tension and intelligent scares, finding synthesis between these two reemerging genres. However, this new film proves even more nebulous, and despite now having popular source material to work with, his intellectual and pulp impulses continue to be at odds with each other, and while the latter is as sharp as it's ever been, the former drowns in a cliched, expository script, where an actual human core to the story has been sacrificed in favour of imaginative digital effects. Like fellow writer-turned-director Taylor Sheridan's Wind River, Annhilation is an extremely taut demonstration of Garland's astonishing formal skill, and yet it's the thing he made his name on which falters.
As a slow, tense genre movie with strong world building, however? It's not half bad!